EJP congratulates Smith Gee Studio on receipt of a 2021 CNU Charter Award for Kirkpatrick Park in Nashville! EJP led the Envision Caycee master planning effort.
ROBERT STEUTEVILLE MAY. 5, 2021
Kirkpatrick Park in Nashville, Tennessee, is a catalyst for mixed-income, public housing transformation, designed around a “woonerf.” Smith Gee Studio won a 2021 CNU Charter Award in the Block, Street, and Building category.
The 4-acre Kirkpatrick Park sets a standard for how to build mixed-income public housing in Nashville—an example that could be emulated elsewhere in the US. The development mixes public, workforce, and market-rate housing in nearly equal measure, side-by-side in close proximity. Instead of the visual redundancy that most public housing sites are known for, Kirkpatrick Park includes fifteen distinct 2- to 3-story residential buildings in varieties of townhouses, stacked flats, and townhouses over flats.
The rents of higher-income residents subsidize those of lower-income residents, providing net positive cash flow for the Metropolitan Development Housing Agency, and making the 94-unit development, completed in 2019, economically self-sustaining. Kirkpatrick Park is a catalyst for a larger, 83-acre transformation of Nashville’s largest public housing project, Cayce Homes.
Kirkpatrick Park plan, top, with townhouses (yellow), townhouses over flats (orange), and flats (red). The maps below show how the development fits into the existing and future Cayce Homes.
“Kirkpatrick Park skillfully sets the stage to reknit the community with an interconnected street design and a mixed-income mixture of missing middle housing,” says Rick Bernhardt, former Metro Nashville planning director. “It is a strategic design that reunites a walkable neighborhood and provides a model for other areas torn apart by previous urban renewal and public housing policies.”
The site is a former underutilized park—so that no Cayce Homes residents were displaced. All units are built to the same market-rate standards, inside and out, and designed to meet LEED for Homes (Silver) protocols. “My new home is more beautiful than I could have ever imagined. I am just overjoyed,” says Geraldine Watkins, a former Cayce resident.
The two-block development is built around a central “woonerf,” a unique addition to public housing. This pedestrian-oriented street offers safe play and gathering space overlooked by front porches, stoops, and balconies. This woonerf gives Kirkpatrick Park a unique identity. Although cars may navigate and park on the street, they travel very slowly and the space clearly is designed for people on foot and bicycle.
Kirkpatrick Park woonerf.
Two pocket parks also flank the Kirkpatrick Park site. One, at roughly 7,000 square feet, is composed of rubberized mound play surfaces creating a safe environment for children to have creative play (see photo at top). The other is roughly 2,500 square feet of bioretention transformed into a usable gathering area. Each park offers seating and communal intersections to tie into the existing and future neighborhood. The bioretention is part of an ambitious sustainable site development program, including reduced stormwater generation due to infiltration infrastructure.
To enable Kirkpatrick Park to kick-off the ambitious Cayce Homes redevelopment without displacement, MDHA created a Redevelopment District and design guidelines, rezoned 83 acres, purchased a 12.6-acre adjacent Section 8 housing complex, and closed a city park. The development is named after the closed park. The closure is temporary, as the public space will be recreated elsewhere in the larger redevelopment. The project’s new, smaller, public spaces are now better utilized than the namesake park.
Kirkpatrick Park is located about a mile, across the Cumberland River, from downtown Nashville. Situated near one of the major gateways into East Nashville, a gentrifying urban neighborhood filled with high-priced single-family homes with high rates of owner-occupancy, Kirkpatrick Park needed an especially robust public process and consensus amongst the various stakeholders. Input was sought through a comprehensive community needs survey as well as dozens of public and resident-only meetings.
The development achieves a fairly high density in a way that feels like a Nashville neighborhood and is compatible with surrounding streets and blocks. It has helped to bring walkability, and a high-quality public realm to a part of the city that that is lacking in these qualities.
Smith Gee Studio: Principal firm, architect, urban planner
Metropolitan Development and Housing Agency: Client
R.G. Anderson Company: Construction manager
Hawkins Partners: Landscape architect
Barge Cauthen & Associates: Civil engineer
2021 Charter Awards Jury
Goeff Dyer (chair), Master Planning and Urban Design Strategic Lead, B&A Planning Group
Amy Stelly, Artist, designer, urban planner with Claiborne Avenue Alliance
Marques King, Economic Development and Design Manager with Jefferson East, Inc.
Alli Thurmond Quinlan, principal, Flintlock Architecture & Landscape
Andrew von Maur, Professor of Architecture at Andrews University